One-Stage and Two-Stage Implant-Based Breast Reconstruction

Одно- и двухэтапная имплантная реконструкция груди

How implant-based breast reconstruction after mastectomy works: one-stage or two-stage surgery, prepectoral and subpectoral implant placement, the role of acellular dermal matrix (ADM) and synthetic meshes. An educational overview that helps you prepare for a conversation with your surgeon.

What is implant-based reconstruction?

Implant-based breast reconstruction is one of the ways to restore the shape of the breast after mastectomy using a silicone or saline implant.

Reconstruction can be performed at the same time as mastectomy or started later. Depending on the condition of the tissues and the treatment plan, a permanent implant is placed immediately, or a temporary tissue expander is used first.

The choice of method depends not only on the patient’s desire to have a breast of a certain size. The condition of the skin and soft tissues after mastectomy, the anatomy of the chest, the characteristics of the tumour, the need for radiation therapy, the state of health, smoking, and the expected volume of reconstruction are all important.

Therefore, there is no universal «best» method of reconstruction.

One-stage reconstruction: a permanent implant right away

In one-stage reconstruction, the permanent implant is placed during the same operation as the mastectomy. This option is sometimes called direct-to-implant reconstruction.

The main advantage is that the patient does not need a separate stage with a tissue expander and a subsequent operation to replace it.

However, suitable conditions are required. The skin envelope after mastectomy must have sufficient volume and good blood supply, and the tissues must allow the implant to be closed safely without excessive tension.

The size and position of the implant must also be selected taking into account how the tissues will look after healing. The possibilities for changing the volume after placement of a permanent implant are limited compared with expander-based reconstruction.

One-stage reconstruction is therefore not suitable for all patients.

Two-stage reconstruction: first the expander, then the implant

In two-stage reconstruction, a tissue expander rather than a permanent implant is placed during mastectomy.

The expander is a temporary device whose volume is gradually increased, usually by injecting saline through a special port. This allows the volume to be gradually built up and the soft tissues stretched to the size needed for subsequent reconstruction.

After the expansion stage is complete, a second operation is performed: the expander is removed and replaced with a permanent implant.

This approach takes more time and involves at least two operations, but it gives the surgeon more opportunities to gradually build up volume and adjust the shape.

Two-stage reconstruction is especially often considered when the condition of the tissues after mastectomy does not allow a permanent implant to be placed safely right away, or when treatment involves additional stages, including radiation therapy.

At the same time, the fact that radiation is planned does not mean that two-stage implant-based reconstruction will necessarily be the optimal option. In some situations, radiation therapy becomes an argument in favour of a different reconstructive approach.

Where is the implant placed?

After mastectomy, the implant can be positioned differently relative to the pectoralis major muscle.

Subpectoral placement

In subpectoral reconstruction, the implant is located partially or completely under the pectoralis major muscle.

The muscle creates an additional layer of tissue over the implant and can provide more natural coverage of its upper part. However, placing the implant requires working with the pectoral muscle, which may be accompanied by postoperative pain, changes in the implant’s position when the muscle contracts, and so-called animation deformity.

When the pectoral muscle tenses, the contours of the reconstructed breast may change noticeably.

Prepectoral placement

In prepectoral reconstruction, the implant is located in front of the pectoralis major muscle — directly under the skin and subcutaneous tissues.

The main difference is that the pectoral muscle is not used to cover the implant and is usually not divided for its placement.

This allows problems associated with muscle contraction, including animation deformity, to be avoided or reduced. In some cases, this approach is also accompanied by less postoperative pain and faster recovery of pectoral muscle function.

But prepectoral reconstruction has an important condition: there must be a sufficiently good layer of soft tissue over the implant.

If the skin after mastectomy is too thin or its blood supply is impaired, the contours and edges of the implant may be more noticeable, and the risk of problems with the skin envelope is higher. Therefore, choosing prepectoral placement requires a careful assessment of the tissues.

Why are ADM and synthetic meshes needed?

During reconstruction, the implant must be reliably covered and stabilized.

In some cases, additional materials are used for this — acellular dermal matrix (ADM) or synthetic meshes.

ADM is a biological material obtained from human or animal tissue from which the cells have been removed. What remains is an extracellular matrix consisting mainly of the structural components of the tissue.

A synthetic mesh is made of an artificial material and performs a mechanical supporting function.

These materials can be used as an additional framework for the implant. They help hold it in the desired position, support the lower pole of the reconstructed breast, and create additional coverage where there is not enough native muscle tissue.

In prepectoral reconstruction, such materials are especially often used to form and stabilize the pocket around the implant.

However, ADM or mesh are not needed for every patient. Their use depends on the chosen surgical technique, the condition of the tissues, the type of reconstruction, and the experience of the particular surgical team.

The use of additional material also means additional cost and certain risks. Possible complications include seroma, infection, inflammatory reaction, and healing problems. The specific risk profile depends on the material, the technique, and the patient’s characteristics.

What happens to the implant over time?

An implant is not a lifelong device, even if the initial reconstruction was successful.

Over time, complications or changes in the shape of the reconstructed breast may occur that require monitoring or additional surgery.

Possible problems include:

  • capsular contracture — tightening and contraction of the scar capsule around the implant;
  • change in the position or shape of the implant;
  • asymmetry;
  • visible rippling or contours of the implant;
  • seroma or infection;
  • rupture of the implant shell;
  • the need to replace or remove the implant.

A silicone implant may have a so-called «silent» rupture, in which there are no external signs of a problem. Therefore, imaging methods are used for silicone implants to assess their condition.

If a saline implant ruptures, the fluid is usually gradually absorbed by the body, and the implant itself noticeably loses volume.

The specific follow-up schedule depends on the type of implant, the manufacturer’s recommendations, the country, and the individual situation. Therefore, the patient should ask the surgeon in advance what follow-up will be required after the chosen type of reconstruction.

What is BIA-ALCL?

A rare disease is associated with breast implants — breast implant-associated anaplastic large cell lymphoma (BIA-ALCL).

This is not breast cancer, but a rare disease of the immune system. Its development is most closely associated with certain textured implant surfaces.

Most often, BIA-ALCL does not manifest immediately after surgery, but years later. Possible signs include sudden or gradually increasing fluid accumulation around the implant, breast enlargement, induration, or the appearance of a mass.

The probability of this complication is very low, but a new swelling or other unusual changes in the area of the reconstructed breast a long time after surgery require an in-person assessment.

At the same time, the presence of an implant in itself does not mean that the patient should expect BIA-ALCL to develop.

How does radiation therapy affect reconstruction?

Radiation therapy after mastectomy can significantly affect the choice of reconstruction method and its result.

Radiation can worsen the condition of soft tissues and increase the risk of complications with implant-based reconstruction. These include healing problems, infection, implant loss, and the development of pronounced capsular contracture.

Therefore, the question of whether radiation therapy is needed should preferably be resolved before the final choice of reconstructive strategy.

If radiation is planned, the surgical team may offer different options:

  • temporarily place an expander and postpone final reconstruction to a later stage;
  • perform implant-based reconstruction taking the planned radiation into account;
  • consider autologous reconstruction using the patient’s own tissues;
  • use a combined approach.

It cannot be said that implants are always contraindicated with radiation therapy. However, the risk of complications and the likelihood of subsequent revision surgery become important factors when choosing a method.

What to choose: implant or own tissues?

Implant-based reconstruction is not the only option.

In autologous reconstruction, the patient’s own tissues are used to create the breast, for example skin and subcutaneous fat from the abdomen or other donor areas.

Implants have obvious advantages: there is no need to create a donor area, and the operation as a whole may be less extensive than some variants of reconstruction with own tissues.

Autologous reconstruction, in turn, allows the breast to be created from the patient’s own tissues and does not require a permanent implant. But it is a more complex surgical intervention with an additional operative area and its own risks.

Therefore, the choice between an implant and own tissues depends on the medical situation, anatomy, oncological plan, and the patient’s own preferences.

What should be discussed with the surgeon before surgery?

At the consultation, it is useful to get answers not only to the question «which implant will be placed», but also to understand the entire reconstruction plan.

You can ask in advance:

  • whether reconstruction can be performed at the same time as mastectomy;
  • whether a one-stage option is suitable or an expander will be needed;
  • where the implant will be located — prepectorally or subpectorally;
  • whether ADM or synthetic mesh will be needed;
  • how the condition of the skin after mastectomy affects the choice of method;
  • whether radiation therapy is planned and how it will change the reconstruction;
  • how many operations will presumably be required;
  • what changes in sensation are possible;
  • how likely additional correction is in the future;
  • what follow-up will be required after implant placement;
  • what the surgical team will do if infection, seroma, impaired healing, or another problem occurs.

Such questions help compare not individual technical details, but the entire reconstruction journey.

Key points

Implant-based breast reconstruction after mastectomy can be performed immediately with placement of a permanent implant or in stages — first with a tissue expander, then with a permanent implant.

The implant itself can be placed in front of the pectoralis major muscle or partially/completely under it. The prepectoral technique preserves the muscle and avoids animation deformity, but requires a good condition of the skin envelope and sufficient soft tissue coverage. The subpectoral technique uses the muscle to cover the implant but may be accompanied by specific problems associated with its contraction.

ADM and synthetic meshes are used not as an obligatory part of any reconstruction, but as additional materials to support and stabilize the implant in certain surgical situations.

The choice of method is most strongly influenced by the condition of the tissues after mastectomy, the characteristics of the tumour process, the need for radiation therapy, the patient’s anatomy, concomitant factors, and her own goals.

Therefore, the right question at a consultation is not «which method is the best?» but «which reconstruction option is most suitable for me, taking into account my oncological treatment, the condition of my tissues, and the result I want to achieve?»

This material is informational in nature and does not replace a consultation with an oncologist, mammologist, or plastic surgeon. The specific reconstruction strategy, implant choice, and need for additional materials are determined individually.