If you have a significantly increased risk of developing breast cancer, your doctor may offer several options to reduce it. In some situations, prophylactic mastectomy is discussed; in others, more intensive surveillance or medical risk reduction.
A separate question arises if cancer has already been found in one breast: should the healthy second breast be removed? This operation is called contralateral prophylactic mastectomy (CPM). It is not suitable for everyone and does not automatically mean that the health risk will be lower to the extent it may seem.
The choice depends on your baseline risk, the results of genetic testing, family history, the characteristics of the cancer already detected, and personal preferences. Therefore, prophylactic surgery makes sense to consider after discussing all available options with an oncologist and a surgeon.
What is risk-reducing mastectomy?
Risk-reducing, or prophylactic, mastectomy is an operation that may be considered in a woman without diagnosed cancer if the probability of its development is substantially higher than usual.
One of the best-known high-risk factors is certain inherited gene variants, such as BRCA1 and BRCA2. However, the decision about surgery is not made on the basis of a single genetic test result alone: the combination of factors and the individual situation are taken into account.
In bilateral prophylactic mastectomy, the tissue of both breasts is removed. This can significantly reduce the probability of developing breast cancer, but does not eliminate it completely. After surgery, some tissue may remain in the area of the skin, chest wall, or other anatomical zones.
How much the risk is reduced depends on the baseline situation and the method of surgery. Therefore, it is more correct to speak of a substantial reduction in risk rather than its complete elimination.
What is CPM?
CPM is contralateral prophylactic mastectomy, that is, removal of the second, outwardly healthy breast in a woman in whom cancer has already been detected or was previously detected on one side.
Here it is important to distinguish between two situations.
In bilateral prophylactic mastectomy, there is no cancer at the time of surgery. The goal is to reduce the probability of its occurrence in a woman with a high baseline risk.
In CPM, cancer already exists or existed in one breast. The second breast is removed to reduce the risk of developing a new cancer in it.
For most women with unilateral cancer without signs of substantially increased hereditary or other specific risk, removal of the healthy second breast is not an automatically necessary part of treatment. In some groups of women it may have more grounds, so the decision is made individually.
At the same time, CPM is a full-fledged operation with its own risks, recovery, and the possibility of subsequent interventions. Therefore, it is important to weigh the potential benefit in your specific situation against the consequences of removing a healthy breast.
When can prophylactic surgery make sense?
Risk-reducing mastectomy may be discussed if the probability of developing cancer is substantially increased. The reason may be inherited variants of certain genes, a pronounced family history, or some other circumstances.
But high risk does not mean that surgery is necessarily required.
Before making a decision, the doctor may offer:
- genetic counselling and, if necessary, testing;
- more intensive surveillance using appropriate imaging methods;
- medical risk reduction, if such an option is suitable;
- prophylactic mastectomy;
- declining surgery now with the possibility of returning to the question later.
For one woman, surveillance will be the most acceptable option; for another, surgery. What matters here is not only the risk calculation, but also how comfortable you are with the uncertainty associated with regular surveillance.
What is important to discuss before surgery?
Prophylactic mastectomy changes the body, even if it is performed with subsequent reconstruction. Therefore, before surgery it is worth discussing not only the reduction of oncological risk, but also the consequences for everyday life.
In particular, it makes sense to talk in advance about:
- the possibility of breastfeeding in the future;
- skin and nipple sensation;
- the appearance of the breast and scars;
- sexual perception of one’s own body;
- the need for one or several operations;
- possible complications and the duration of recovery;
- reconstruction options or the possibility of declining it.
If nipple preservation is important to you, this should also be discussed in advance. The possibility of preserving it is determined not only by aesthetic wishes, but also by oncological safety.
What to do after mastectomy: reconstruction or flat closure?
After removal of the breast, you have several options. Reconstruction can be performed immediately during mastectomy or postponed to a later date.
The main approaches include:
Implant reconstruction. An implant is used to restore volume, sometimes after preliminary tissue expansion with an expander. This option usually involves a shorter operation compared with reconstruction using your own tissues, but the implant may require subsequent corrections or replacement.
Reconstruction with your own tissues. Tissue from your own body, for example from the abdominal area, is used to create the breast. Such reconstruction allows a soft volume to be formed without a permanent implant, but it is a more complex surgical intervention and leaves an additional area of scarring.
Aesthetic flat closure. Some women do not want to restore breast volume after mastectomy. In this case, the surgeon creates the smoothest possible contour of the chest wall, taking into account the anatomy and the patient’s wishes.
External prosthesis. Instead of surgery, a removable prosthesis can be used, which is placed in a bra or special clothing.
Delayed decision. Sometimes after mastectomy it is reasonable not to make a decision about reconstruction immediately. You can return to this question later if circumstances or personal preferences change.
None of these options can be called universally best. What matters is your lifestyle, your attitude to surgery, the condition of the tissues, the treatment plan, and how you want your body to look after treatment.
How does radiation therapy affect reconstruction?
If we are talking about prophylactic mastectomy in a woman without cancer, radiation therapy is usually not part of such treatment. However, with CPM the situation may be different: treatment of the cancer already detected sometimes includes radiation.
Radiation therapy can affect the skin and soft tissues and increase the likelihood of certain reconstruction complications. Therefore, in unilateral cancer, the plan for surgery and reconstruction should preferably be discussed with an oncologist and a plastic surgeon before mastectomy.
Sometimes this influences the choice between an implant and reconstruction with your own tissues, as well as the timing of individual stages.
What complications are possible?
Breast reconstruction may be accompanied by infection, bleeding, impaired healing, seroma formation, and skin problems. Depending on the method, complications associated with the implant or the transferred flap are possible.
With implant reconstruction, displacement, rupture, capsular contracture, and the need for additional surgery may occur. With reconstruction using your own tissues, problems are possible in the area of the transfer and at the site from which the flap was taken.
After mastectomy, skin sensation may also change. Even if the nipple is preserved, its sensation may differ from what it was before surgery.
The probability of specific complications depends on the chosen method, the condition of the tissues, concomitant factors, and the characteristics of treatment. Therefore, when planning surgery, it is important to discuss with the surgeon not only the expected result, but also possible recovery scenarios.
Do you need to make a decision right away?
Not always.
If prophylactic surgery is not urgently required, you usually have the opportunity to obtain a second opinion, undergo genetic counselling, learn about surveillance and reconstruction options, and only then make a decision.
It is especially important not to perceive prophylactic mastectomy as the only way to «make the risk zero». Its task is to substantially reduce the probability of disease in certain situations, but not to eliminate it completely.
If you have already been diagnosed with cancer, the question of CPM should be considered separately from the treatment of the tumour itself. In this case, it is important first to determine the scope of the necessary oncological treatment, and then, together with the team, assess whether removal of the second breast will provide significant additional benefit specifically for you.
It is important to distinguish prevention from diagnosis
Prophylactic surgery does not replace examination.
If you have found a new lump, retraction or skin change, nipple discharge, a change in its shape, or another unusual symptom, a diagnostic examination is necessary first. Such a situation cannot be considered a reason for prophylactic surgery without clarifying the cause of the changes.
After treatment for cancer or prophylactic mastectomy, the recommended surveillance plan must also be followed.
Key points
Risk-reducing mastectomy and CPM are different situations, although both operations involve removal of breast tissue.
If you have a high hereditary or other risk and are considering prophylactic mastectomy, it is useful to compare it with surveillance and other ways of reducing risk.
If cancer has already been detected in one breast, removal of the second, healthy breast is not a mandatory decision for every woman. The potential benefit depends on individual risk, and the operation itself is associated with consequences for appearance, sensation, and recovery.
Whichever option you are considering, it is advisable to make a decision after a calm discussion with an oncologist, a surgeon, and, if necessary, a genetic counsellor. It is important to understand not only the possible reduction in risk, but also how the chosen path will affect your body, further treatment, and quality of life.


